Building LeBetter Flats, part 8, Portland South Waterfront residential buildings

The NCC chose for the Flats a model of lowish podiums (7 stories) with mid rise towers above (another 7 stories, 14 floors in total). Portland’s South Waterfront is decidedly much more highrise. It is, no doubt, what Ottawa planners have wet dreams about when they imagine the Preston-Carling area in 30 years time with its snowstorm of highrises. I very much doubt we will achieve that.

I gather the NCC and Claridge are negotiating to abandon the rest of the existing low and mid rise LeBreton Flats plan (east of Booth Street) to build much taller towers on the remaining lots closer to Booth Street. So the South Waterfront vs LeBreton Flats comparison is useful for both what is currently underway and what the next bits of the Flats might shift towards.

The Portland development is several phases ahead of the NCC. LeBreton Flats didn’t get its office component of mixed use (two 11 storey towers at the SE corner of Booth/Wellington, until recently a bomb pit) whereas SWaterfront has a busy medical complex attracting employees, students, and patients. That building brings many people to the site and populates the parks and commercial mainstreet.

Pictures tell the story:  leaving the transit plaza along the streetcar tracks that wind around the Medical building  shown in the previous story, the newest highrises do loom high:

IMG_1775

 

Podiums and differentiated architecture at the bases attempt to anchor them and create a more intimate street level environment:

IMG_1777

 

Balconies are generous size, and well used, as is possible in the milder Portland climate. Nonetheless, Ottawa continues to amaze me as having the cheesiest smallest balconies on its buildings compared to just about anywhere else I’ve been.

 

IMG_1779

 

New buildings are modern in style and scale:

 

IMG_1778

 

Curves, modulated facades, and varied materials are tricks in the architects’ bags, but aren’t enough to make these human relatable; the SWaterfront buildings are imposing; the LeBreton buildings are much more pedestrian friendly:

 

IMG_1796

 

Unusually angled balconies attempt to create interest. Recall from part 1 of this series, a similar balcony design is employed on the newest building on LeBreton Flats facing the aqueduct:

 

IMG_1800

 

below: the view from the next development site back to the taller towers. Note the attempt at a podium and low rise element:

IMG_1795

 

A podium in brick below a glass tower; half the tower is clad in brick to “trick” the eye into seeing two slimmer towers (here in Ottawa, similar efforts went into the new condos by Place Bell and Windmill’s Cathedral Hill. Does it work?)

 

IMG_1792

 

Even amongst the tallest towers, some shorter buildings attempt to recreate a human scale for pedestrians; I felt a flush of relief, a loss of tension, when I came across these low rise bits:

 

IMG_1784

IMG_1791

 

(below)  An array of older buildings, very simple, with few balconies. I think these were student housing for the adjacent University. A number of ground floor apartments opened directly onto the sidewalk. I wondered if they were supposed to evolve into commercial locations as demand grows, as they had zero setback and privacy from passersby:

 

IMG_1794

 

At the end of one street, by  a luxury condo tower, the next development site awaits. The low rise housing is visible in the distance, furthest from the River and closest to the elevated freeway:

 

IMG_1816

 

next: walking the South Waterfront sidewalks …